We have added search box. Key in SAP issue keyword to search
TopBottom

Announcement: wanna exchange links? contact me at sapchatroom@gmail.com.

RE: [sap-basis] Security Transports Moving Prematurely

Posted by Admin at
Share this post:
Ma.gnolia DiggIt! Del.icio.us Yahoo Furl Technorati Reddit

Posted by Dave Thornburgh (SAP JOAT)
on Oct 6 at 11:47 AM
Al -

It's easy as a Basis guy to forget (or not even know in the first place) that the one object <-> one request rule applies only to Dictionary objects. Customizing, Security roles and profiles, and many other things like them can and sometimes do exist in multiple requests at the same time. The gotcha, then, is that any time ANY of the multiple requests is released, the state of the object at the time of release - including everybody else's changes - is what gets recorded in the transport files. The ONLY solution is complete transparency - as you said, communication, management, and cooperation.

Dave

---------------Original Message---------------
From: Al Fournier
Sent: Thursday, October 06, 2011 10:24 AM
Subject: Security Transports Moving Prematurely

Keith, along with communication is management and cooperation. That being said, there appears to be a misunderstanding of the Change Management System. Objects can only be changed in one request at a time. There may be many tasks in a request and each task may be owned by a different user. Your original message implied that transports were being imported in an uncontrolled manner - management and cooperation would prevent this. The duplication of the changes in client 300 and then 100 is foolish and potentially problematic. You should fully test what is in the transport that is being released. You can do this by creating the transport in 100 and then testing it in 300 by using transaction SCC1 to "move" it to 300, test there, and then release it in 100 for other systems. You can use SCC1 while the transport is unreleased, go back and fix it, if necessary, and when complete release it. Why do double the work?

__.____._
Copyright © 2011 Toolbox.com and message author.

Toolbox.com 4343 N. Scottsdale Road Suite 280, Scottsdale, AZ 85251
Mark as helpful
View this online
  
Dave Thornburgh
SAP Basis Helper

Posted helpful replies on 5 threads in a group to earn a Bronze Achievement
Popular White Papers

In the Spotlight
Have an SAP Question? Ask Your Peers at Toolbox for IT

_.____.__

0 comments:

Post a Comment

T r a n s l a t e to your language